SIGMUND MONTAG, Sworn In For The State, 79th To Testify

Reading Time: 6 minutes [923 words]

SIGMUND MONTAG, sworn for the Defendant.

I am engaged in manufacturing stationery. I am treasurer of the

National Pencil Company. The company receives its mail at my office,

which is two blocks from the pencil factory. Frank comes to my office

every day of the year to get the mail and instructions with regard to orders

and the business of the factory. He came to my office on April 26th,

about ten o'clock and stayed about an hour. He talked to me, my stenographer, Miss Hattie Hall, and Mr. Gottheimer, one of the salesman. Up to about a year ago I went to the factory almost every Saturday afternoon. Mr. Frank would always be working at his desk on the financial

sheet. The telephone in my house is 20 feet from my bed. I did not hear

it ring Sunday morning. My wife was aroused by its ringing and she

waked me. The man at the other end asked me if I could identify a girl

that was killed in the basement of the pencil factory. I referred him to

Mr. Darley who was most familiar with the help in the factory. After

breakfast Mr. Frank came to my house. It was a raw, chilly morning.

He was no more nervous than we were about the murder when we saw him that morning. I was very much agitated and trembled. My wife

was very nervous and commenced to cry. I saw no marks, scratches or

discolorations of any sort on his face, and there were no spots on his

clothing. I went to the factory that morning and made a general examination, including the metal room. We saw nothing on the floor. Frank was very much nervous and agitated when he told us about the occurrence. We have a great many accidents in the metal room. They would be brought to the front of the building into the office. I heard that about nine o'clock Monday morning Mr. Frank had been taken to police headquarters. I knew that he had a very limited acquaintance there and I

therefore telephoned for Mr. Herbert Haas, my personal counsel and

counsel for the pencil company to go down there. Mr. Haas answered

that he didn't like to leave home that morning, that his wife was expecting

a new arrival, so I sent my automobile after him. Mr. Haas came

back and said he was refused admittance to Mr. Frank at the station

house, and said he was going to telephone Mr. Rosser. He then tele-

phoned for Mr. Rosser. That was between half past ten and eleven. Mr.

Rosser came down to the station house thirty or forty minutes later. I

saw Mr. Rosser go upstairs. About forty minutes later Mr. Black and

Mr. Haas left police headquarters with Mr. Frank. I always received

the financial sheet on Monday morning. Mr. Frank would bring them

over in envelopes. I saw the financial sheet of April 24 1913 (Defendant's

Exhibit 2) on Monday afternoon about three o'clock. That was after

Mr. Schiff called me over the telephone and asked me if I would sanction

the employment of the Pinkertons to ferret out this crime, and I told Mr.

Schiff to go ahead. I told him and Mr. Darley to help the authorities all

in their power to find out the murderer, whoever he might be.

CROSS EXAMINATION.

Mr. Frank was well acquainted with our attorney, Mr. Haas. He

was president of the B'nai B 'rith. The B'nai B'rith has between four

or five hundred members, I should say. When I say that Mr. Frank had

a limited acquaintance, I meant that the people around police headquarters

did not know Mr. Frank. Mr. Frank did not ask for an attorney.

Mr. Schiff told me that Mr. Frank had spoken to him about employing

the Pinkertons. Mr. Frank was very nervous when he was at my house Sunday morning. He had already been to the undertaker's. He told me they had taken him into a dark room and flashed on a light, and he said

he saw the little girl there. He described how she looked. He said her

face was scratched and her eye was discolored, and she seemed to have a

gash in her head. Her mouth was full of sawdust and he described her

in a general way. He did not call my attention to his being nervous. He

did not say anything to me about an attorney or having been to police

headquarters. I don't know whether he had been to police headquarters

or not. I authorized the employment of the Pinkertons on Monday. I

had not then employed counsel. My sending Mr. Herbert Haas to see

Mr. Frank was not employing counsel. I made no trade with Mr. Haas.

Don't know who is paying his fee. I have not contributed anything towards

it, nor has the Pencil Company. The Pencil Company is employing

the Pinkertons. As to whether they have been paid yet or not, they

haven't requested their pay. They have sent bills two or three times. I

received the reports from the Pinkertons. They came sometimes every

day and then sometimes they didn't for a few days. I got the report

about finding the big stick and the pay envelope. I did not request the

Pinkertons to keep the finding of the stick and the envelope from the

police and authorities. We have little accidents almost every two weeks

in the factory. There was one big accident about a year ago, a machinist,

Gilbert, had his head bursted open in the metal department. That

was about a year ago. The insurance company ordered us to clean up

the factory about a week after Mary Phagan's death.

RE-DIRECT EXAMINATION.

Superintendent Pierce, of the Pinkertons, told me that his reports

would be furnished to the police before they came to me.